I know, right after I say this is going to be primarily a Canadian soccer I post a Manchester United article. But this is a special case. The following is a look at Manchester United’s formation in the match against Celtic in Toronto and how it may apply to the season to come. It’s written by a Canadian Stretford End reader, Scott Westbury. So Enjoy! (and don’t worry I’ll be back with Canadian coverage in the coming week).
Although officially on the big board in Toronto Manchester United lined up in a 4-3-3, or what looked on the team sheet to be a 4-4-2 with Berbatov & Diouf up front with (l-r) a midfield of Giggs, Fletcher, Scholes and Obertan. The actual deployment of the players on the pitch was somewhat different, and resembled more of a 4-2-3-1.
Berbatov operated somewhat alone up front often hugging one of the centre-backs when not in possession. Obertan took on a traditional right wing role. What was interesting though was the positioning of Giggs & Diouf. Giggs almost exclusively operated on the left, as did Diouf. Effectively Sir Alex was overloading the left side.
This also left extra space for Celtic’s Shaun Maloney down the opposition left, who created problems in the United defense with his runs in the first half for Celtic.
Scholes and Fletcher provided holding midfield roles with Scholes never straying far up the pitch unless United were enjoying lengthy possession. At a depth roughly the same as the two fullbacks. Scholes was hitting long accurate balls to either wing.
If Giggs was making the run down the left, Diouf angled into the middle but usually behind the level of Dimitar Berbatov – this was probably designed to pull the 2nd centre-back away from Berbatov – allowing him to get in front of his marker. If Diouf extended down the left with his pace, Giggs slid over into the middle in front of the back 4 for Celtic. The overload of the left side, and the space creation of Berbatov is seen perfectly in the replays of Dimitar’s goal in the first half.
Obertan makes the break out of the United third and Berbatov drifts off to the right, creating space for Obertan to dribble, push out to Diouf, and you can see Berba’s run into the box clearly.
This is something Berbatov is extremely adept at doing – making space for other players in attack. We’ve all seen him ‘drift’ in and out of games on the television – and he does it in person too. What he’s really doing is making space, and practicing the fine art of ‘getting lost’ from the centrebacks. As they find him again, it stretches the defensive structure
By getting Diouf or Giggs into the hole United is exploiting a positional flaw at the heart of the EPL, and British football/soccer in general – the man in the ‘hole’, or the false ‘nine’. Withdrawing this player to a level in between the defenders but behind the midfield has been a nightmare for all 4-4-2 based teams. Eric Cantona exploited this space perfectly in the past for us – what was 4-4-2 on a team sheet was truly more of a 4-2-3-1 or 4-4-1-1 (Paul Merson did this for Arsenal too, and was never utilized at an international level for it). England has never dealt with this alignment well either, and the answer’s typically been to push up the backline, thereby reducing the pace such players (Herr Ozil for example) have to operate. This would be a decent answer, but is a glass house with relaxed offside-laws and doesn’t bode well if your central defenders lack pace (Hullo John Terry – we’ll never know how much England missed Rio I think). We have the 2nd half of the England-Germany contest as evidence of this.
Rooney has filled this role in the past for us, and Berbatov looks like he can do it as well, albeit differently. Berbatov doesn’t seem to sink back into midfield, but instead offers lateral movement that creates space. Obertan’s goal against Kansas City’s MLS squad shows it beautifully. The run up is all Johnny Evans, but what springs Obertan is NOT Evan’s run or Obertan’s speed – it’s the subtle drift of Berbatov away from the pass that opens the seem to spring Obertan free.
United’s changes in the second half clearly allowed them to get into more of fluid 4-2-3-1 as seen to the left, with the front four constantly rotating and moving through the various positions. United’s last two goals show the rotation perfectly, and on Cleverly’s deflection you can see the movement and rotation that was going on throughout the second half.
This hearkens back to the 2008-2009 season where Tevez, Giggs, Ronaldo, Park and Rooney prowled up front for much of the season. Their rotation and movement constantly making it very baffling for opposition defenses.
It looks like Sir Alex is trying to replicate this with the current squad. One of the problems last year was Berbatov hadn’t settled into a role up front – and Antonio Valencia really is only a right sided players which cuts down on the movement up front. The upside is IF Berbatov can play that lead role and be that front man it could open up space for Rooney to do something that strikes fear into opposition defenders – run AT them. Rooney wasn’t allowed (or couldn’t because of the short comings of Emile Heskey) to do this for England this summer. If he can for United it will be because of Dimitar Berbatov up front who plays that lone striker role much like VanPersie did for Holland, who opened up the game for Snejder, Kuyt & Robben.